Go to page 1, 2
  Forum » Doubts and questions » Offside totally messed up! Date
Username
212 msgs.
Substitute
Rather comically:

10:59 The linesman seems popular all of a sudden...he is surrounded by players after that offside call against Antonio Soriano.
11:33 Good call by the linesman- Luis Fabián Sarnari was clearly in an offside position.
12:20 Good call by the linesman- Luis Fabián Sarnari was clearly in an offside position.

http://uk.strikermanager.com/partido.php?id=4411429

This is me checking the first few minutes, I have another 16 offsides to check....but it seems if my player comes back from an offside position to chase a pass made by the opposition, he is deemed to be offside. Which is wrong!!!

Having lost this game, I am not really bothered as I have a comfortable league position but I could be a different story if I was only ahead by a few points and this cost me a win....please fix.

Thanks

./Ghost
22/02/2012 20:24
  - Div/Gr
Fiscal
6832 msgs.
Golden Ball
The offside bugs are in the top 10 bug fixing list! 22/02/2012 20:47
  Steel City - Div4/Gr64
Username
6256 msgs.
Golden Ball
ghostdawg said:
Rather comically:

10:59 The linesman seems popular all of a sudden...he is surrounded by players after that offside call against Antonio Soriano.
11:33 Good call by the linesman- Luis Fabián Sarnari was clearly in an offside position.
12:20 Good call by the linesman- Luis Fabián Sarnari was clearly in an offside position.

http://uk.strikermanager.com/partido.php?id=4411429

This is me checking the first few minutes, I have another 16 offsides to check....but it seems if my player comes back from an offside position to chase a pass made by the opposition, he is deemed to be offside. Which is wrong!!!

Having lost this game, I am not really bothered as I have a comfortable league position but I could be a different story if I was only ahead by a few points and this cost me a win....please fix.

Thanks

./Ghost


Player was in an offside position when the ball was played, so he's offside.
23/02/2012 08:38
  - Div/Gr
Username
22 msgs.
Child's coach
Actually when the ball is played by opponent then there is not an offside. 23/02/2012 09:30
  - Div/Gr
Username
212 msgs.
Substitute
@grantis45 said:
ghostdawg said:
Rather comically:

10:59 The linesman seems popular all of a sudden...he is surrounded by players after that offside call against Antonio Soriano.
11:33 Good call by the linesman- Luis Fabián Sarnari was clearly in an offside position.
12:20 Good call by the linesman- Luis Fabián Sarnari was clearly in an offside position.

http://uk.strikermanager.com/partido.php?id=4411429

This is me checking the first few minutes, I have another 16 offsides to check....but it seems if my player comes back from an offside position to chase a pass made by the opposition, he is deemed to be offside. Which is wrong!!!

Having lost this game, I am not really bothered as I have a comfortable league position but I could be a different story if I was only ahead by a few points and this cost me a win....please fix.

Thanks

./Ghost


Player was in an offside position when the ball was played, so he's offside.


The opposition passed the ball, my player outran the opposition to get to the ball first....that's not an offside in a million years. I can go and dig up the rule book but I am 150% certain this is the case. Grantis, please don't tell me you designed the offside rules?
23/02/2012 10:58
  - Div/Gr
Username
131 msgs.
Substitute
Yah ive seen an instance where the opponent did a throw in and my player touched the ball and was called offside. Lol 23/02/2012 15:29
  - Div/Gr
Username
212 msgs.
Substitute
lol, again, it is impossible to be offside from a throw in or a corner......comical.




I gather SM dev are actively working on addressing this problem, here is a photo taken of them hard at work fixing the problem

23/02/2012 15:51
  - Div/Gr
Username
6256 msgs.
Golden Ball
Alright, I misread I thought you meant that you passed and that your player came back from an offside position to pick the ball up.

If it's the opponent passing then no it shouldn't be offside. ghostdawg my apologies.

It's on the bug list with throw ins.
23/02/2012 18:54
  - Div/Gr
Username
212 msgs.
Substitute
@grantis45 said:
Alright, I misread I thought you meant that you passed and that your player came back from an offside position to pick the ball up.

If it's the opponent passing then no it shouldn't be offside. ghostdawg my apologies.

It's on the bug list with throw ins.


No need to apologies, thanks for getting it on the list.

./Ghost
23/02/2012 20:56
  - Div/Gr
Username
2108 msgs.
Best scorer
I think that one has always been on this list for a while.

Can we get a list of things on the list that have been fixed?
23/02/2012 21:15
  - Div/Gr
     
Go to page 1, 2
1