| Forum » Doubts and questions » Attributes - Points - Average | Date | |
|---|---|---|
|
Username
6256 msgs.
Golden Ball
|
There are plenty of attributes that you can "see" make a difference in the sim, speed, technique, ball steal, dribbling and passing being the obvious ones. | 30/11/2012 13:53 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
Fiscal
6832 msgs.
Golden Ball
|
@sabrefan62 said: I disagree...I think its pretty clear that individual attributes make a significant difference. Compare two CFs with similar averages...one with high speed and technique and one with very high leadership. The first CF will perform significantly better against defenders during a simulation. That's what I mean I would rather total average not be there as it can be misleading The physical, mental, attack and defence actually make a bit of sense unlike total average Edited by eamwilson 30-11-2012 13:58 |
30/11/2012 13:55 |
| Steel City - Div4/Gr64 | ||
|
Username
1399 msgs.
International
|
@sabrefan62 said: I disagree...I think its pretty clear that individual attributes make a significant difference. Compare two CFs with similar averages...one with high speed and technique and one with very high leadership. The first CF will perform significantly better against defenders during a simulation. you must also see it like this-the first CF has more shot attribute so first CF will also hav more offensive points as compared to 2nd.so he will perform better |
30/11/2012 13:56 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
Username
1399 msgs.
International
|
grantis45 said: There are plenty of attributes that you can "see" make a difference in the sim, speed, technique, ball steal, dribbling and passing being the obvious ones. mate u may be wrong.these attributes u mentioned may not singuarly make a difference but as a whole in form of offensive or physical or defensive points.As a CF with high shots but low dribbling does not perform good as compared to one which is good in both.It can be because of better offense point of 2nd. |
30/11/2012 14:06 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
Username
6256 msgs.
Golden Ball
|
No, I can see a high technique player because of his turning speed and acceleration, that's a physical attribute. Players with very high strength and speed only do not turn well. However a player with the same physical score and low strenght/ high technique do turn well. | 30/11/2012 15:13 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
Username
1399 msgs.
International
|
grantis45 said: No, I can see a high technique player because of his turning speed and acceleration, that's a physical attribute. Players with very high strength and speed only do not turn well. However a player with the same physical score and low strenght/ high technique do turn well. yeah thats how it is but thats not what what i a denying.i am saying that instead of individual attribute the sim may be using these points in comparing players.it may be using physical points as the basis whether he will outrun defs or not nd offense points for whether he may be able to score or not. |
30/11/2012 15:31 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
Username
6256 msgs.
Golden Ball
|
super striker king said: grantis45 said: No, I can see a high technique player because of his turning speed and acceleration, that's a physical attribute. Players with very high strength and speed only do not turn well. However a player with the same physical score and low strenght/ high technique do turn well. yeah thats how it is but thats not what what i a denying.i am saying that instead of individual attribute the sim may be using these points in comparing players.it may be using physical points as the basis whether he will outrun defs or not nd offense points for whether he may be able to score or not. What im saying is that you can see thats not the case and the developers have confirmed thats not the case http://en3.strikermanager.com/foros/hilo.php?id=284955&inicio=0 Edited by grantis45 30-11-2012 17:24 |
30/11/2012 17:23 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
Username
1399 msgs.
International
|
grantis45 said: What im saying is that you can see thats not the case and the developers have confirmed thats not the case http://en3.strikermanager.com/foros/hilo.php?id=284955&inicio=0 Edited by grantis45 30-11-2012 17:24 i really suspect it.As we have seen that s forward with high shots but low other attributes should score high no of goals if only attribute is consideresd but he doesnt.instead one with more balanced attributes scores more even if his goals attribute is more.how is this possible as according with that attribute he must be a goal machine.So i think it is not only singular attribute but it has something to do with those points as i have seen some forwards with high shots but less dribbling flop.it can only be expained if we take points into consideration. remember this is jst a theory nd i might be wrong. |
30/11/2012 17:43 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
Username
6256 msgs.
Golden Ball
|
The reason is, that like real players if he cant get into a decent position because he has low dribbling and speed and technique, then hes not going to score much. I dont mean to put you're idea down too much super, but when you watch any of the simmed games, you can notice individual attributes and how they affect gameplay. Plus it would mean Defenders need high saves to tackle and Cfs would score more if they have high passing. That doesnt seem to be the case. In the old sim when i started, its exactly how the game worked, high charisma created very good mids and the passing stat didnt matter. |
30/11/2012 17:56 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
Username
1399 msgs.
International
|
grantis45 said: The reason is, that like real players if he cant get into a decent position because he has low dribbling and speed and technique, then hes not going to score much. I dont mean to put you're idea down too much super, but when you watch any of the simmed games, you can notice individual attributes and how they affect gameplay. Plus it would mean Defenders need high saves to tackle and Cfs would score more if they have high passing. That doesnt seem to be the case. In the old sim when i started, its exactly how the game worked, high charisma created very good mids and the passing stat didnt matter. ooh..ur point is right.yeah a CF with high pass should score more with my theory.so final verdict:always listen to grantis.  |
30/11/2012 18:07 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
2
