Go to page 1, 2
| Forum » Doubts and questions » Why offside if player is on his own half ? | Date | |
|---|---|---|
|
Username
81 msgs.
Rookie
|
For counter playing teams its huge disadvantage and the rules are known , on own half its never offside so why in this game it is... Is it a bug or its like so and stay like this ? Thanks |
21/02/2013 23:30 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
Username
2897 msgs.
Best scorer
|
If the players are in the other half when the ball was kicked, they can be called offside even if in their own half when receiving the ball. That's been the case whenever I've seen people complain about this. If you have evidence otherwise, please share it. |
21/02/2013 23:52 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
Username
81 msgs.
Rookie
|
@sabrefan62 said: If the players are in the other half when the ball was kicked, they can be called offside even if in their own half when receiving the ball. That's been the case whenever I've seen people complain about this. If you have evidence otherwise, please share it. Uh find to remember all beh here is one example whe i run into more ill put them ... This game: http://en.strikermanager.com/partido.php?id=10024298&accion=simul 12:17 time , central attacker is going up and down but pause the kick time.... he is in own half... U can see that winger is offside but he is not affecting the matter so the offside shuldnt have been... |
22/02/2013 00:01 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
Username
2897 msgs.
Best scorer
|
I know this is going sound picky, but if you watch it on slow motion, the central attacker's right leg is still in the other team's half when the ball is kicked. Its very, very close, but I agree with the offside call in that situation. The sim is all based on mathematical programming, so if the player's position is even one pixel into the other half, the sim will call him offside, even though we may not be able to see it very well. |
22/02/2013 03:00 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
Username
81 msgs.
Rookie
|
@sabrefan62 said: I know this is going sound picky, but if you watch it on slow motion, the central attacker's right leg is still in the other team's half when the ball is kicked. Its very, very close, but I agree with the offside call in that situation. The sim is all based on mathematical programming, so if the player's position is even one pixel into the other half, the sim will call him offside, even though we may not be able to see it very well. Ok maybe its not best possible example even if I dont see offside here so i agree its picky. Im pretty sure I saw more drastic examples but I cant remember exactly in what game but when i run into one Ill put it here... BTW why so little played rounds have simulations to review after , wasnt it last season that we could see more sims from season, now only only 2-3 last rounds.. ? |
22/02/2013 03:25 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
Username
5633 msgs.
Golden Ball
|
Sims have only ever been viewable for a week, then they die  |
22/02/2013 04:42 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
Username
814 msgs.
MVP of the game
|
guys have a look at this 1- 18.57 2- 28.13 3- 37.54 4- 70.56 5- 88.58 > > http://en.strikermanager.com/partido.php?id=9912574 > > > > 4 goals was scored on me from a offside position the striker was ball watching in the offside collects the ball and goes on to score. I just cant understand why no offside call > > can you give me you prospective thanks |
25/02/2013 03:43 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
Username
81 msgs.
Rookie
|
hoyte868 said: guys have a look at this 1- 18.57 2- 28.13 3- 37.54 4- 70.56 5- 88.58 > > http://en.strikermanager.com/partido.php?id=9912574 > > > > 4 goals was scored on me from a offside position the striker was ball watching in the offside collects the ball and goes on to score. I just cant understand why no offside call > > can you give me you prospective thanks I looked only 1 situation and i see u clearly not understand what offside is... It doesnt metter wher your defensive line is it the half center line that matters and that players i way way in his half when pass was played that that couldnt confuse u... There is no offside on own half |
25/02/2013 04:03 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
Username
814 msgs.
MVP of the game
|
i would like more comments hoyte868 said: guys have a look at this 1- 18.57 2- 28.13 3- 37.54 4- 70.56 5- 88.58 > > http://en.strikermanager.com/partido.php?id=9912574 > > > > 4 goals was scored on me from a offside position the striker was ball watching in the offside collects the ball and goes on to score. I just cant understand why no offside call > > can you give me you prospective thanks |
28/02/2013 11:35 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
Username
1184 msgs.
International
|
hoyte868 said: i would like more comments hoyte868 said: guys have a look at this 1- 18.57 2- 28.13 3- 37.54 4- 70.56 5- 88.58 > > http://en.strikermanager.com/partido.php?id=9912574 > > > > 4 goals was scored on me from a offside position the striker was ball watching in the offside collects the ball and goes on to score. I just cant understand why no offside call > > can you give me you prospective thanks you can not be offside in your own half. all those goals the opposing forward received the ball in his own half and then ran into yours. if he was in your half when the pass was made he would have been offside. i would suggest you drag your defenders back a lot other wise this will happen a lot. |
28/02/2013 11:41 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
Go to page 1, 2
1
