| Forum » Suggestions » Lower div should be able to give loans to higher div | Date | |
|---|---|---|
|
Fiscal
3449 msgs.
Best scorer
|
While I think it would be handy to loan to 1 div above yours, it's more realistic the way it is now. In a real world scenario if a lower div team had a good player, the lower div team would either want to play him in their team in hopes of him guiding them to wins, or sell him to get money to buy more players. They wouldn't want to see a star player go to another team better than theirs for a season for free. It does them no good. Same thing here, if you have a player that's good enough to start in a higher division, why wouldn't you want to play him in your division in hopes of getting promotion? (obviously the answer would be someone's training schedule) It also is a hinderance for top level teams. If you had a 95 av player in div 3 and you wanted to give him to your friend in div 2 because he'd need it more than you might, you can't, which would be unfair. Edited by @illex 11-12-2014 16:10 |
11/12/2014 16:10 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
Username
259 msgs.
First-team player
|
When QPR got relegated they loaned out a lot of their high earners to Premier league teams or teams in other nations. Loic Remy went to Newcastle. This same scenario can apply here for instance a div 2 team with div 2 wage bill get relegated then that manger can decide to loan perhaps 3 high wage players to back to teams in div 2 so keeping him in black. | 11/12/2014 16:26 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
Username
3066 msgs.
Best scorer
|
SlimRazor said: You love it hard don't you!! Lol! Let's not take this thread off a good debate That we want to able to loan to higher divisions. And if you look through all the posts every single people in favour of it apart from you. But you decided quote my post and ended with a question mark. So you wanted me to comeback which you don't like. Problem with current rule that when it comes to farming, I had real problem finding a jnr mid trainer in div 5/6. But found two in div 4 who were willing to do swap loan deals. But of course with the current rule I was unable to loan up so deal was scuppered. Being in div 5 means I can't afford 70/80ave players, but in order to improve I should farm and should able to loan my jnrs to whoever I want to. This current restrictions only favour top teams as they get their juniors trained. Had I able to loan up then my two jnr IMs now would be 6/7 ave points better than what they are now. There you have it, so I am in favour of this thread creator. Now go and argue with all others said yes to this thread. Again you taking my QUESTION to your hart. I have replied to you with a question. Thats why there was a questionmark behind it. It looks like this ? Now, why I have replied to you and not the other ones? the 5 of them...because most of them wrote +1, one guy saying the message that the player don't want to go in higher divisin is funny. I agree with that one. And what do I reply or ask to someone that just writtes +1? But that doesn't matter. I did not reply to you to flame you I replied to you to get an answer if you had one. You have answered that I personally don't have such player so discussion over. Now you are giving entire example which you could have answer right away when I ASKED a question. Next time in purpose of discussion, try think before you writte something As for your example, yes it would be highly benefitialy to you to be able to loan out a player to higher division, but that has nothing to do with your claim that it is benifitial to higher division player to not be able to take loans in from lower ivision............................................................................ |
11/12/2014 16:28 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
Username
259 msgs.
First-team player
|
Yet again you are going off on a tangent. None of my replies were inflammatory. Sorry if they seemed that way to you. If higher div teams benefit from loaning from lower div teams then it's actually adding weight to our demands. So i really don't see what you are getting at. | 11/12/2014 16:47 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
Username
3066 msgs.
Best scorer
|
I asked question 2 times politely, once asking actual question and second time trying to explain it and got from you what it seems to me as knee jerking; my apologies if it weren't but trying to cut me of on the first seemed that way to me. What I'm getting at is discussing the suggestion. Don't think suggestion forum would be interesting without discussion. But generally I wasn't sure what you mean by it and wanted to see if I am missing something or what. |
11/12/2014 16:58 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
Username
3765 msgs.
Best scorer
|
Hmmm!  this is weird. . . Lets just conclude on this stuff, I think lower division should have the chance and previlege to loan a player to higher Division. |
11/12/2014 21:36 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
3
