Forum » Suggestions » online reward | Date | |
---|---|---|
is this a good idea?
|
||
Username
3066 msgs.
Best scorer
|
Andresholly said: I think this is a good suggestions, I want the @fiscal to do something about it Fiscals will soon as they see your post start handing out free golden balls. |
10/03/2015 15:08 |
- Div/Gr | ||
Fiscal
4046 msgs.
Best scorer
|
I think at its core this is a reasonable enough suggestion. I agree the numbers offered by OP are asking a lot from the devs (not the fiscals btw), but I can see the underlying point of the suggestion and don't believe it has been given the respect it is due by everyone here, if we respect what is meant by a suggestion. The game runs not just on GB sales but also on advertising and promoters, who would like to see people stick around for the duration. I also agree there are some here who will only be happy when the game is entirely free, which, given the lack of a suitable replacement revenue stream plan often missing with such suggestions, cannot be feasible. However, I do think there can be some logic in giving a sample of the good GB life based on the duration for which you've played the game. There are many solely mobile users, and we all know how difficult it is to win promotion after Div 6 using just a mobile, so for many of them, after any promotion from Div 6 the GBs dry up. I'm not suggesting the GBs be used to 'help' the managers, but rather as an ecouragement to a) keep playing and b) consider buying GB to get ahead in the game. I would argue that a modest, time-based reward could be an idea in encouraging some of them to spend more once they see how useful it can be to find good juniors or upgrade the coaching staff. It would need to be sufficiently small so as you could not live for free on it, nor could it be too detrimental to those who buy anyway so as to cannibalize existing sales, like a tiny sample in a supermarket. I'm not talking of giving away big bucks. Anyone who proposes an idea with numbers is going to be slated whatever. "Too high" or "Too low" will be the cries from varous factions of those here. Still, I will try: - I propose 50GB to be gifted when a manager comes of age at 8000exp points, to encourage the use of GB search. - I then propose 50GB to be gifted every calendar year after the manager's start date. This may even deter multi accounts and others who try to cheat, who knows. - Finally, I propose that the gifting of free GB from the game be on the basis of receiving no sanctions from the @s whatsoever in the given calendar year period described in the previous point. There, that's my suggestion. I think I've been fair and respectful to all parties, and opened a discussion on resonable grounds, but let's see what I get back |
10/03/2015 15:42 |
- Div/Gr | ||
Fiscal
4207 msgs.
Best scorer
|
sicox86 said: I think at its core this is a reasonable enough suggestion... ...I'm not talking of giving away big bucks. Anyone who proposes an idea with numbers is going to be slated whatever. "Too high" or "Too low" will be the cries from varous factions of those here. Still, I will try: - I propose 50GB to be gifted when a manager comes of age at 8000exp points, to encourage the use of GB search. - I then propose 50GB to be gifted every calendar year after the manager's start date. This may even deter multi accounts and others who try to cheat, who knows. - Finally, I propose that the gifting of free GB from the game be on the basis of receiving no sanctions from the @s whatsoever in the given calendar year period described in the previous point.... (shortened quote for length only) I think this sounds reasonable enough in as much as it is a birthday present of sorts. I may go so far as to say that the amount for the 8k experience level be 250GBs - enough to check FC/Prog of max number of juniors in their squad. The last point, however, is really a thank you for honest managers and I think it not necessary. The reason people receive sanctions is either a) stupid screw-up and didn't bother to tell a fiscal so it could be fixed or b) massive cheating that has really nothing to do with GB's; pure and simple greed/lack of patience to play the game properly to build up cash. So I'll give it a + 2/3rds. |
11/03/2015 03:34 |
FC need more holidays - Div4/Gr7 | ||
Username
3066 msgs.
Best scorer
|
sicox86 said: I think at its core this is a reasonable enough suggestion. I agree the numbers offered by OP are asking a lot from the devs (not the fiscals btw), but I can see the underlying point of the suggestion and don't believe it has been given the respect it is due by everyone here, if we respect what is meant by a suggestion. The game runs not just on GB sales but also on advertising and promoters, who would like to see people stick around for the duration. I also agree there are some here who will only be happy when the game is entirely free, which, given the lack of a suitable replacement revenue stream plan often missing with such suggestions, cannot be feasible. However, I do think there can be some logic in giving a sample of the good GB life based on the duration for which you've played the game. There are many solely mobile users, and we all know how difficult it is to win promotion after Div 6 using just a mobile, so for many of them, after any promotion from Div 6 the GBs dry up. I'm not suggesting the GBs be used to 'help' the managers, but rather as an ecouragement to a) keep playing and b) consider buying GB to get ahead in the game. I would argue that a modest, time-based reward could be an idea in encouraging some of them to spend more once they see how useful it can be to find good juniors or upgrade the coaching staff. It would need to be sufficiently small so as you could not live for free on it, nor could it be too detrimental to those who buy anyway so as to cannibalize existing sales, like a tiny sample in a supermarket. I'm not talking of giving away big bucks. Anyone who proposes an idea with numbers is going to be slated whatever. "Too high" or "Too low" will be the cries from varous factions of those here. Still, I will try: - I propose 50GB to be gifted when a manager comes of age at 8000exp points, to encourage the use of GB search. - I then propose 50GB to be gifted every calendar year after the manager's start date. This may even deter multi accounts and others who try to cheat, who knows. - Finally, I propose that the gifting of free GB from the game be on the basis of receiving no sanctions from the @s whatsoever in the given calendar year period described in the previous point. There, that's my suggestion. I think I've been fair and respectful to all parties, and opened a discussion on resonable grounds, but let's see what I get back Fine, well put thought. The thing is, this is comletely different to what OP proposed. So it could be said it is completely separate suggestion/idea. This one I can agree with. Numbers....free should be minimal IMO, so if for login, I'd say 10 GB for 7 day login or something like that. As for other games, Facebook games specifically. Some games probably do give away some stuff but from the little I tried on facebook none of the games was worth spending time on it with their flashy graphics and poor content and none of them gave away what OP or Jenson proposed. They gave away equivalent to what I am saying here. 10 GBs for 7 day login. (approx) Edited by ForzaJuve! 11-03-2015 11:29 |
11/03/2015 11:28 |
- Div/Gr | ||
Username
87 msgs.
Rookie
|
How did you want them to make there profit that is bad suggestion pls | 21/03/2015 04:52 |
- Div/Gr | ||
Username
268 msgs.
First-team player
|
Would never happen, no one would spend money on GB's so they would lose out on alot of money. Edited by liverpool6792 21-03-2015 14:45 |
21/03/2015 14:44 |
- Div/Gr | ||
Username
501 msgs.
MVP of the game
|
Where do you get the motivation to keep on suggesting things from? This game is dead. | 31/03/2015 11:24 |
- Div/Gr | ||
Username
932 msgs.
MVP of the game
|
Game is definitely not dead, it just runs in smaller circles... Now in regards of the suggestion it is a bit simple and there is no way any dev would go for it. It lacks any real tangible solutions to any REAL problem, if your problem is you don't have GB's then learn to play with out them. I can tell you you can more than get by without them. +Sicox86 has the right idea! A time based (not daily login) would be a nice addition to incentivize "US" to keep coming back on the regular. The GB's reward should be extremely minimal none of this 10GB's for 7 day login in. That is way too much and the devs wouldn't cosign for it. If you keep it stingy we probably could get a reward based GB system approved by the devs while keeping the regular GB users happy and new users from complaining. LETS BE HONEST SOMEONE WILL ALWAYS COMPLAIN |
05/04/2015 18:15 |
- Div/Gr | ||